As we continue to reflect on our January 2026 predictions for restructuring and insolvency, we revisit the two key cases we highlighted as “ones to watch”:
Drelle v Servis-Terminal LLC [2026] UKSC 29
In January we highlighted the forthcoming appeal from the Court of Appeal’s conclusion that an unrecognised foreign judgment could not support an English bankruptcy petition. The Supreme Court has now unanimously reversed that decision, holding that an unrecognised and unregistrable foreign judgment for a debt or definite sum of money may constitute a “debt” for the purposes of section 267 Insolvency Act 1986. The decision removes the need for separate recognition proceedings in the circumstances addressed by the judgment and is likely to be welcomed by foreign creditors seeking access to English bankruptcy proceedings. As we discussed in an article on the Supreme Court judgment in July, there is clearly potential for the same principles to be applied in respect of corporate insolvency proceedings.
Noal SCSp v Novalpina Capital LLP [2025] EWHC 1392 (Ch)
The first-instance decision in Novalpina adopted a strict interpretation of the MVL regime, requiring debts, including contingent and disputed liabilities and interest, actually to be paid within the 12 month period stated in the declaration of solvency. The judgment prompted concerns that standard MVL practice would be affected, and the strict requirement could in particular cause difficulties for practitioners dealing with MVLs involving unresolved tax liabilities or disputed claims. At the date of writing, the Court of Appeal’s decision is awaited and will determine whether that strict approach is maintained. In the meantime, however, the Insolvency Service published a review of MVL practice and outcomes, which indicated, based on a sample of over 2,000 MVL cases commenced between 2015 and 2024, that creditors were paid within 12 months in 95% of cases. 100% recovery was achieved for creditors in all but three completed cases (these converted to CVL). Conversions to CVL are, however, rare – only 0.3% of the sample.
The Insolvency Service review indicates that perhaps the Novalpina decision will have less impact on routine MVL practice than feared – however there remains a small proportion of more complex cases which will be affected. The long-awaited Court of Appeal judgment will therefore be welcome to provide further clarification.