The recent Technology and Construction Court (TCC) decision in Serapid Ltd v Octavius Infrastructure Ltd [2026] EWHC 2695 (TCC) is an important reminder of the risks involved in commencing works without an agreed contract in place. In this case the paying party successfully resisted enforcement of an adjudicator’s decision on the basis that there was no agreed contract between the parties, despite the fact that a contract had been the subject of protracted negotiation. Therefore, the adjudicator had no jurisdiction to make his decision in the first place. This question over the existence (or not) of a contract was also the subject of consideration in the TCC earlier this year – see our article here
Background
- Serapid Ltd (Serapid), a specialist lift manufacturer, entered into contract negotiations with the main contractor Octavius Infrastructure Limited (Octavius) for the supply and installation of lifts at Chalkwell Railway Station (Chalkwell).
- Octavius and Serapid had previously contracted in relation to similar schemes at other railway stations, and Octavius sought to engage Serapid in the light of that existing relationship. The parties had previously also entered into a formal subcontract in August 2024 for design services at Chalkwell.
- In December 2024, Octavius invited Serapid to tender for supply and installation of the lifts at Chalkwell. It provided that the contract for the lift works would be subject to a standard NEC3 Engineering and Construction Subcontract. Serapid issued a quote to Octavius in February 2025, which included Serapid’s own general terms and conditions.
- On 20th May 2025 Octavius issued a draft NEC3 subcontract to Serapid and asked for any comments back asap. On 27th May Serapid responded with a substantial schedule of comments and proposed amendments. Contract negotiations continued (including in relation to the contract price) and at some point during this period Serapid started manufacturing items in connection with the works. On 28th October Serapid issued a new quotation repricing the works at a higher price than the original quote.
- On 7th November 2025, Octavius informed Serapid that Network Rail no longer required its services and denied owing Serapid any contractual obligation in relation to the lift works. This was disputed by Serapid who maintained that a contract had been concluded and it was entitled to recover the costs it had incurred to date in the sum of £667,526.
The Adjudication
Serapid referred the matter to adjudication maintaining that the parties had entered into an NEC3 subcontract ‘on or around 6 June 2025’ and that Octavius had wrongfully terminated the contract. Octavius challenged the adjudicator’s jurisdiction, arguing that no contract existed between the parties and therefore the adjudicator had no jurisdiction to decide the dispute in the absence of a contract.
The adjudicator found that a contract had been formed between the parties, on the basis of a NEC3 form of contract and that substantive agreement had been reached, with only minor terms left to be agreed. The adjudicator found that on that basis Ocatvius had wrongfully terminated the contract and was liable to pay certain sums to Serapid as a result. The adjudicator awarded Serapid £416,499. Octavius failed to pay the awarded sum.
Serapid made an application for summary judgement to enforce the adjudicator’s decision. Serapid argued that a contract was agreed on or about 6th June 2025 on NEC3 terms, or in the alternative, Serapid argued that there was a ‘simple oral contract’ between the parties, not on NEC3 terms. This alternative case had not been argued in the adjudication. Serapid argued that the existence of a contract on either of these cases would have given the adjudicator jurisdiction to decide the dispute, either under the NEC3 subcontract terms, or under Part 2 of the Scheme for Construction Contracts (England and Wales) Regulations 1998. Octavius resisted enforcement of the adjudicator’s award, maintaining that no contract existed between the parties in relation to the works.
What did the court decide?
As you will no doubt be aware, in order for the parties to adjudicate, there must be a construction contract in place. Therefore, if there was no contract in existence between the parties, the adjudicator would have no jurisdiction to decide the dispute, and his decision would not be enforced by the court.
The court considered three key questions in relation to whether or not the adjudicator’s decision should be enforced:
- Was a contract agreed on NEC3 terms on 6th June 2025, or later in June 2025?
- Alternatively, did the parties enter into a “simple oral contract”?
- Did Octavius have a real prosect of establishing that the parties had not entered into any contract, whether on NEC3 terms or as a simple oral contract?
1.The existence of a NEC3 Sub-contract
As noted above, the adjudicator had found that a contract existed on the relevant NEC3 terms, due to the parties reaching substantive agreement on the price and envisaged programme of the works. However, the court did not agree.
The court held that there was substantial evidence to suggest neither side regarded the parties as bound by the NEC3 contract which was discussed in or around June 2025. For example, Serapid had issued a revised quotation during contractual negotiations which took place some months later, indicating that the price of the works had not been agreed.
The court highlighted Serapid’s inability to “clearly pinpoint a time in which the bargain was struck, when the relevant offer was made or acceptance received”. In particular, the court noted that the fact that Serapid had commenced procurement in June 2025 did not necessarily indicate that the contract terms had been agreed, or at least substantially agreed, at that time.
The court made it clear that on applying the facts to legal principles, the parties had not intended to create legal relations. The court looked at what had been communicated by words or conduct between the parties and decided that on this set of facts, it was uncertain whether a contract had been formed.
2. Whether an alternative simple oral contract had been formed
The court rejected Serapid’s alternative argument that a simple oral contract had been formed, holding that this was not pleaded and had also not been put to the adjudicator during the adjudication. Furthermore, it was held that there was no clarity as to by whom or in what circumstances the oral contract was agreed, or as to the offer or acceptance, price or scope.
The court also found that Serapid’s reliance on this alternative case amounted to a “tacit recognition” that Octavius had a real prospect of defeating the primary case (that a contract existed between the parties on the NEC3 terms) further weakening Serapid’s argument.
3. Did Octavius have a real prospect of successfully arguing that no contract existed?
The court found that, among other things, Octavius had a real prospect of establishing that no contract had been concluded, given the vagueness of Serapid's primary and alternative cases, the absence of a signed agreement despite requirements for execution as a deed, continued negotiation between the parties after June 2025 on fundamental aspects of the contract, such as the price, and contemporaneous documentary evidence suggesting neither party regarded itself as bound.
The court found that since Octavius had a real prospect of showing there was no contract between the parties, the adjudicator did not have jurisdiction over the dispute, and his award was not enforceable.
Key takeaways:
- This case highlights the need for parties to consider their intentions during contractual negotiations and to clearly set out what has been agreed and when.
- If a party commences performance of a proposed scope of work, this does not necessarily establish the existence of a contract. Parties should therefore be wary of incurring the costs of early services and/or long-lead items without some sort of written signed agreement in place.
So, however urgent the works may be, the clear direction from the court is that parties should endeavour to put a formal agreed signed contract in place sooner rather than later. This will give certainty over the substantive terms and also prevent arguments about an adjudicator’s jurisdiction which may lead to a party being unable to enforce an adjudication award in its favour.